I run Undebt.it, so read this knowing where I stand. I have tried to keep it factual, and everything about Debt Payoff Planner below comes from their own site as of September 2026. If something changes on their side, tell me and I will fix it.
The short version
Both tools do the core job: enter your debts, pick snowball or avalanche, get a debt free date and log payments against it. They differ on platform, on how many payoff strategies they offer, on pricing model, and on how much detail they show.
Side by side
| Feature | Undebt.it | Debt Payoff Planner |
|---|---|---|
| Platform | Web app, any browser, add to home screen on mobiles | iOS and Android apps, plus web |
| Free plan | Unlimited debts, every payoff method, Excel export, compare page | Yes, "everything most people need" |
| Paid plan | Undebt.it+, $10 a year, paid once, no auto renewal, 30 day trial with no card | Pro from $2 a month, billed through the app stores |
| Payoff methods | Snowball, avalanche, hybrid, cash flow index, custom order and four more | Snowball and avalanche |
| Compare methods with your numbers | All methods side by side | Snowball vs avalanche |
| Extra payments | Debt snowflakes, unlimited per month, negative ones too | One time extra payments |
| Account required | For the planner only; calculators need no signup | Yes, account creation is step one |
| Bank connection | No; YNAB (& SimpleFIN-coming soon!) sync for Plus members | No |
| Promo APR support | Yes, free | Yes |
| Ads | None on calculators or Plus; some in the free member area | See their current listing |
| Who runs it | One person, since 2012 | OxbowSoft LLC, since 2015 |
Where Debt Payoff Planner is the better pick
If you want an icon from the App Store or Google Play, push notifications and the least possible setup, it is a polished app and a million downloads say people like it. If you only ever intend to use snowball or avalanche, its two strategy design is a feature, not a limit.
Where Undebt.it is the better pick
If you want to see what a hybrid order or a cash flow index order does to your date before you commit, only one of the two will show you. If you want a month by month table with every payment on it, exportable to Excel, that is what the snowball table is for. If you would rather pay $10 once a year than a monthly app store subscription, or you split time between a phone and a desktop, a web app that logs in anywhere fits better. And if you never want to install anything, add the site to your home screen and it behaves like an app.
What neither does
Neither tool links directly to your bank. You enter balances and log payments yourself in both. That is a deliberate privacy trade in Undebt.it's case: no credentials shared, no aggregator in the middle, at the cost of a few minutes a month.
Switching from Debt Payoff Planner
Your debts are just names, balances, rates and minimums. Enter them on the quick start grid and you will have the same plan in Undebt.it in a few minutes, plus the other methods to compare it against.